Sport

The Search for the Heir: 6 Midfielders to Replace Casemiro at Old Trafford

17.02.2026
Editor edt

It seems the focus has shifted from high-end romance to the “Engine Room” at Old Trafford! Since we are looking at 2026, the transition away from the Casemiro era is officially the top priority for Manchester United.

Here is the breakdown of the six primary candidates to inherit the throne of the five-time Champions League winner.

The Hunt for the Heir: 6 Midfielders to Replace Casemiro

With Casemiro’s departure confirmed for the end of this campaign, United are looking for a younger, high-energy “enforcer” to stabilize their midfield. While a permanent manager is still unconfirmed, these six names are at the top of the scouting list:

1. Carlos Baleba (Brighton)

  • The Profile: The 22-year-old Cameroon international is the closest stylistic match to a prime Casemiro—aggressive, energetic, and a defensive wall.

  • The Catch: Brighton is holding out for over £100 million. However, clearing Casemiro’s £350,000 weekly wage makes this financial hit much easier to swallow.

2. Adam Wharton (Crystal Palace)

  • The Profile: At 21, Wharton is considered a “generational” English talent. He offers elite passing range and tactical intelligence.

  • The Verdict: He’s more of a deep-lying playmaker than a pure destroyer. He’d need a defensive partner to truly thrive at United.

3. Elliot Anderson (Nottingham Forest)

  • The Profile: A rising star for England under Thomas Tuchel. He is “combative and all-action,” possessing the athleticism United has lacked in midfield.

  • The Status: Reports suggest he is United’s priority target, though his price tag could also eclipse the £100 million mark.

4. Sandro Tonali (Newcastle United)

  • The Profile: The “safest bet” in terms of experience. At 25, he has Champions League pedigree and international maturity with Italy.

  • The Opportunity: If Newcastle fails to secure Champions League football, Tonali might be available at a discount as he enters the final two years of his contract.

5. Éderson (Atalanta)

  • The Profile: A “press-resistant” Brazilian who was vital to Atalanta’s Europa League success.

  • The Value: With only 18 months left on his contract, the 26-year-old represents a cost-effective, high-IQ replacement for his compatriot.

6. Angelo Stiller (VfB Stuttgart)

  • The Profile: An unorthodox choice. Stiller is a creative force (11 assists last season) who also maintains defensive discipline.

  • The Fit: Like Casemiro, Stiller offers a dual threat: he can stop an attack and immediately start one with a progressive pass.